I mentioned some time ago in one of the workshops checklists I use to run through and edit/fix/improve my writing.
Editor's checklist:
- is every character and every place adequately and uniquely described?
- in these descriptions, do you use descriptive ("fat" or "$10") or specific ("lean") words? You want to use specific detail only.
- search for -- and immediately destroy -- cliches.
- Look for unneccesary words and word multiples.
I borrowed this one from an article Lisa Dale published.
Scene Craft Checklist: Below is a checklist to help writers craft stronger scenes in their fiction or nonfiction (novels, memoirs, short stories, essays, or other creative prose).
- Does the scene begin on a strong note?
- Does your scene have a strong setting that supports the action? Do the characters interact meaningfully with the setting?
- Do you use the five senses to drive home the physical details of the scene and make it come alive?
- Does the description convey the mood via focus and language choice? Is the mood consistent with the action?
- Is there strong characterization through present action, with only the most necessary backstory?
- Are the characters doing something to move the action forward in the narrative present?
- Is the point of view carefully controlled and consistent-no "head-hopping"?
- If there are POV changes, is the reader prepared for such shifts with scene breaks?
- Is there emphasis on action over summary?
- Is the dialogue believable? Does each character speak in a unique voice? Is there a good balance of dialogue, internal monologue, description, and summary?
- Does the scene have one main plot point? Is that plot point moved forward successfully and clearly?
- Are minor plot points kept to a minimum?
- Is the scene focused (have you taken pains to make sure that description, dialogue, setting, characterization, summary, and all other elements don't veer off course away from the main plot)?
- Does the resolution reinforce the mood? Does the resolution of the scene imply further action; Does this scene lead into another scene in order to keep the action moving forward?
- Does the scene raise questions, deepen conflict, or otherwise lead by pointing to a forthcoming scene? Is your scene "undeletable" so that if you took it out, the whole plot would crumble?
- Does the scene end on a strong note?
- Do a visual check. If the scene is strong, you'll have a balance of "white space" and "gray space" with a variety of dialogue, description, and plenty of paragraph breaks-all of which should be visible to a reader who is just skimming the pages.
Let's add whatever good stuff we can think of and really use the checklists. It can save a lot of time and struggle trying to figure out what's not working, and a lot of these tips add tons of life to a piece.
This has some good stuff to
This has some good stuff to check for in first drafts, which one shouldn't expect to be really good and polished anyhow. But these are some things that you can go through pretty quickly when your head is still too much in the piece to do any serious cutting and stuff, that will leave the writing less cluttered so that people can see what the content is really like.
http://www.be-a-better-writer.com/creative-writing-tips.html
These are really great things
These are really great things to check for! And I think we all should use these checklists on our writing. My only quibble is with the fact that there are going to be minor scenes which will move the action along, but might not pass all of the tests, since they are not major scenes in the story that need to be so strong. Not to say that you should have weak scenes in your stories or essays, just that you need to know what your filler is and what's crucial to your plot line. I suppose all scenes are pretty major scenes in nonfiction essay writing though. Lisa Dale certainly has a lot of things to check for. But what she says about there being a good balance of dialogue, internal monologue, description, and summary is very true.
Any work of creative writing
Any work of creative writing shouldn't have a single word of filler in my opinion.
I agree that not all scenes are going to meet these standards though.